// you’re reading...

breakfast, collingwood, restaurants and cafes, under $20

NOT: Cavallero, 300 Smith St, Collingwood

P1030487v1 NOT: Cavallero, 300 Smith St, Collingwood

As regular readers will know, I’m a going-out-for-breakfast skeptic. I toast my own granola, soak my own bircher, bake my own bread and flip some pretty awesome pancakes (the trick is to separate the eggs). I get the weekend papers delivered to my doorstep and I have a large sunny balcony in which to read them.

I admit that my early-morning cooking exploits and fortunate living arrangements make me a minority, but it means that on the rare occasions that I do go out for breakfast, I expect something beyond what I could rustle up from my store cupboard ingredients.

Sadly, Cavallero did not deliver.  I was so disappointed – its wrought iron entrance, airy warehouse ceiling, funky moose-head on the wall, 50s diner booths and constant bustle of cool locals had me itching to try the venue ever since I moved to the neighbourhood.

P1030490v1 NOT: Cavallero, 300 Smith St, Collingwood

Nevertheless, at breakfast we’re talking a menu with zero innovation. Out of our table of four, three of us didn’t even order from the breakfast menu because there was nothing that caught our fancy (muesli, eggs, eggs, eggs and eggs). Instead, we opted for toasted sandwiches. Toasted sandwiches, people! The kind that any 5 year old can make with bread, ham and cheese (even if they may not use Istra ham and Heidi Farm gruyere).  I don’t need to be paying $8.50 for that. My eggplant kasundi sandwich didn’t even have toasted bread, and contained a fridge-cold filling. The fourth person of our party did succumb to the eggs (baked), which was quote ‘nothing special’.

P1030491v1 NOT: Cavallero, 300 Smith St, Collingwood

P1030499v1 NOT: Cavallero, 300 Smith St, Collingwood

The one redeeming part of the experience – the coffee was good…although they initially forgot the order.

I really wanted to like Cavallero but I can’t really recommend it over other, better breakfast options in the vicinity such as Gluttony It’s a Sin, Proud Mary and Birdman Eating. I like the space a lot and the lunch/dinner menu seems to offer more interesting choices, so I may give it another try just to be fair. But for the moment, my breakfast experience leaves it a NOT.

minilink NOT: Cavallero, 300 Smith St, Collingwood

pixel NOT: Cavallero, 300 Smith St, Collingwood

Discussion

11 comments for “NOT: Cavallero, 300 Smith St, Collingwood”

  1. I have to agree that breakfast isn’t their strong point. It used to be much better but had always been slim for options. I rarely go unless I feel like an omlette which is great. As for the coffee, mediocre always for me, never terrible but never great. You must have got lucky there!
    go back for dinner! Then fish is great, new menu now but the pork neck is nice as well.

    Posted by Ben | December 6, 2009, 11:02 am
    • Hi Ben

      Once again I walked past Cavallero this morning and was astounded by the massive crowd inside. Now that I’ve had a taste of their breakfast offerings, I’m wondering who are the people that keep frequenting it when there are so many better options around?

      Perhaps I will go back for dinner, as they must be doing something right.

      Jetsetting Joyce

      Posted by Jetsetting Joyce | December 6, 2009, 10:00 pm
  2. I put Birdman Eating in the same bucket. I think the best breakfast place in the vicinity is Min Lokal.

    Posted by Hookturns | December 6, 2009, 6:33 pm
    • Hi Hookturns

      I do think that Birdman Eating has some more imaginative items on the menu compared to Cavallero – such as the black rice, coconut yoghurt and mango and coconut quinoa porridge with banana and palm sugar. My main gripe with Birdman Eating is that its enormous weekend queues means that I often get the hunger grumps by the time I finally get my breakfast. Hence I only tend to go in the early morning.

      I’ve never been to Min Lokal but will be sure to check it out; thanks for the tip. I’ve also heard Cibi is very good – have you been?

      Jetsetting Joyce

      Posted by Jetsetting Joyce | December 6, 2009, 9:54 pm
      • Interesting to see your thoughts on Cavallero – I like many others am not a fan (That Jess Ho recently did a post on her dislike of Cavallero and there were a huge number of comments from people who had terrible experiences). I had an awful breakfast there and have never been back.

        I agree with Hookturns, Min Lokal is very good (interesting baked eggs – think pumpkin & preserved lemon etc). Cibi has a pretty short menu but their Japanese breakfast is pretty special and nice if you want to feel a little virtuous as its pretty healthy. Probably not something you would rustle up at home either!

        My other local suggestion is Squirrel in Clifton Hill… happy breakfasting!

        Posted by Emily
        Twitter: em_itpleasesus
        | December 15, 2009, 9:54 pm
  3. Oh and I have had dinner at Cavallero a few times (a while back I admit) and while it was originally quite good, most recently it has been average. That said, maybe Ben is right and it has come good again…
    .-= Emily´s last blog ..Shocolate’s mammoth macaron =-.

    Posted by Emily
    Twitter: em_itpleasesus
    | December 15, 2009, 9:56 pm
  4. I would have to agree with you on this one. My vegan girlfriend did like the porridge with caramelized nuts and poached fruit there, but I found it pretty unimaginative. When we went for dinner it was pretty much the same. A great place with some interesting breakfasts is Southpaw in Gertrude street! The scrambled tofu and the salmon eggs are both great dishes…

    Posted by Rane | January 5, 2010, 9:45 pm
    • Hi Rane

      Consensus seems to be that dinner may be a better option at Cavallero, but there’s been no emphatic recommendations – so coupled with my breakfast experience I think I’m going to give Cavallero a miss from now on. Thanks for the tip about Southpaw too – I have no idea why it has passed me by, as it’s right in my neighbourhood. I love scrambled tofu as well, so will definitely try it.

      Jetsetting Joyce

      Posted by Jetsetting Joyce | January 6, 2010, 10:30 am
  5. [...] Cavallero(300 Smith St, Collingwood +61 3 9417 1377) and Min Lokal (422 George St, Fitzroy +61 3 9417 0333) – for coffee, baked eggs and people watching. [...]

    Posted by Mel: Hot or Not – The Decisive Guide to Melbourne | A Vintage Affair | September 22, 2010, 5:33 pm
  6. The food was nice but diner was ruined by pretentious and pushy waiting staff.
    And when you’re trying to pay the bill (over $80 for two), you’re told “NO eftpos” and rudely sent to the 7 eleven to get cash out.
    Next time I’ll just walk out and never come back.

    Posted by Igor | January 5, 2012, 12:03 am

Post a comment

Twitter ID
(ID only. No links or "@" symbols)

Welcome to MEL: HOT OR NOT

The decisive guide to Melbourne

Reviews of what's HOT and NOT in the city.

Recent Posts

HOT: Ebi Fine Food, 18A Essex St, Footscray
July 21, 2014
HOT: Luna1878 Night Market, Queen Victoria Market, cnr Elizabeth and Victoria Streets, Melbourne + Giveaway!
July 18, 2014
HOT: Southgate Moveable Feasts at Artusi, Amarok and Bluetrain, Southgate Precint, 3 Southgate Ave, Southbank
July 16, 2014
HOT: Parisian Patisserie Boulangerie, 19 Keilor Rd, Essendon
July 14, 2014

Click for more in Archives

Get in touch

Want to say hello, ask questions, give feedback, advertise on the site? Email me at joyce@melhotornot.com

LIKE me on Facebook

We’re featured in LonelyPlanet.com

I'm a featured blogger on Lonely Planet
MEL: HOT OR NOT - The decisive guide to Melbourne Melbourne restaurants

Twitter Updates

    Categories

    Editorial policy

    Get Adobe Flash player